Archive for July, 2009

Reflections on General Convention 2009

Tuesday, July 21st, 2009

TO: The Diocese of West Texas
FROM: Bishops Lillibridge and Reed
RE: Reflections on General Convention, 2009

- It is Monday morning, July 20, and now that we have had a couple of days rest we want to offer you some of our reflections on General Convention, which met in Anaheim from July 8-17. We are grateful to all of you who have held us, the diocesan deputation, and the entire General Convention in your prayers. We have heard from many in our diocese – thanks for our actions, disappointment in our actions, curiosity about where we go from here, and more. We cannot answer each message individually, but sincerely appreciate the care and the hope that you all have expressed for our Church and our diocesan life.

It is impossible to share with you the totality of the General Convention experience and actions in a brief article such as this. However, we want to take a moment to discuss the issues that are making headlines and were at the forefront of this Convention, and we will have other opportunities to deal with the Convention in a broader context in the weeks and months ahead.

As expected, the Convention revolved around issues of human sexuality. The primary questions before the Convention were whether or not to overturn resolution BO33 (2006-B033 Resolution) from General Convention 2006, and whether or not the moratoria requested by the Instruments of Communion of the worldwide Anglican Communion would continue to be observed by The Episcopal Church. These moratoria include, in the words of BO33, “exercising restraint by not consenting to the consecration of any candidate to the episcopate whose manner of life presents a challenge to the wider church” (widely understood to mean partnered gay bishops). A different, but related, question was whether or not we would authorize the development of liturgies for same gender blessings. Two resolutions were passed dealing with these questions.

The issue surrounding the ordination to the episcopate of a partnered gay cleric was handled in resolution DO25 (2009-D025 FINAL VERSION – Concurred). We encourage you to read the entire resolution (available on our diocesan website or will be soon), but let us note a section here. While not specifically repealing BO33, it states that the General Convention recognizes “that gay and lesbian persons who are part of such relationships have responded to God’s call and have exercised various ministries in and on behalf of God’s One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church and are currently doing so in our midst” and “that God has called and may call such individuals to any ordained ministry in The Episcopal Church.” The office of bishop is included in the words “any ordained ministry”. Technically speaking, the moratoria will stand until a partnered gay bishop is elected and ordained, but the spirit of the resolution clearly moves The

Episcopal Church into new territory. The Instruments of Communion will have an interpretation on whether this is a rejection of one of the moratoria requested of The Episcopal Church.

Resolution CO56 (C056 Current Variant) calls for “an open process for the consideration of theological and liturgical resources for the blessing of same gender relationships” and “That the Standing Commission on Liturgy and Music, in consultation with the House of Bishops, collect and develop theological and liturgical resources, and report to the 77th General Convention” (to be held in 2012). In addition, the resolution acknowledges “That bishops, particularly those in dioceses within civil jurisdictions where same-gender marriage, civil unions, or domestic partnerships are legal, may provide generous pastoral response to meet the needs of members of this Church;” and “That this Convention honor the theological diversity of this Church in regard to matters of human sexuality…” . Put plainly, bishops may authorize blessings for same-sex unions but are not required to do so. This resolution moves The Episcopal Church away from clear acceptance of the Communion-wide moratoria in this area.

Both of us voted against these two resolutions. We did not vote this way because we believe that gay and lesbian persons have no place in the Church. There are many factors at work in our Church and in the Communion at present.

First, we believe that the moratoria asked of us (The Episcopal Church) should continue as the Anglican Covenant process continues to move forward. It should be completed by the end of this year and sent to the Provinces for consideration. The Covenant idea was first proposed in the Windsor Report (2004), to which this diocese has repeatedly committed itself over the past several years.

Second, the Archbishop of Canterbury attended the opening of General Convention and specifically asked this Convention not to take actions that would further divide the Communion.

Third, the Theology Committee of the House of Bishops has begun a comprehensive study of the issues of homosexuality, entitled ”A Theological Study of Same Sex Relationships.” The committee is a diverse group of lay and ordained persons; bishops, priests, and consulting theologians; straight and gay persons; conservatives, liberals, and moderates; who will develop a study “that will present the full range of views prevalent in the church today on the theological and ethical teaching about same sex relationships…and provide a study document explaining each position in the clearest possible way, presenting current scriptural studies and theological and ethical perspectives within the cultural contexts of The Episcopal Church…The Study will include relevant scientific and medical/psychological data.” They anticipate a final draft no later than March 2012, perhaps sooner.

For the above reasons and more, the two of us believed that not moving forward on the issues raised in resolutions DO25 and CO56 would have provided the church with additional space in which to abide with one another as we wrestle with the whole range of views and practices in these

matters. We believe that this theological homework needs to be done at this critical time in the life of the Anglican Communion and The Episcopal Church.

Declining to move forward in these matters would have also sent a strong message to the Archbishop of Canterbury and the wider Communion that we know this is a long, difficult road and that we respect our relationships with them enough to continue to offer restraint in these areas. At the same time, we acknowledge the reality that many in this church believe we have already waited long enough and the time to move forward is now. This was reflected in the debate and conversations that the most important thing at this moment was to “state clearly and honestly” where the majority of the Convention believes this church to be.

In all of this, we are hopeful that the work of the Theology Committee, given a fair hearing, will be an important contribution to our walk together, and especially as the Diocese of West Texas continues to have these conversations. As you may remember, we have a Reconciliation Commission developing a framework for discussions in these and other areas.

Clearly, we are living in a time of great change in society and in the Church. Clearly, we have gays and lesbians in the Diocese of West Texas who are hurting because of their experience in the Church, and because we have voted the way we have on these matters. Clearly, we have conservatives in West Texas who continue to be frustrated by the actions of the General Convention. Clearly, your bishops have the pastoral responsibility for all of the members of our diocese as well as a responsibility to and with the wider Church. Clearly, balancing all of this is a challenge for even the most gifted of leaders. We want to assure you all that we are committed to your service in the Name of Christ, our own clay feet notwithstanding.

The larger issue in all of this is, of course, what it means to be a Christian in the 21st century. In many parts of the globe, Christianity is in decline and that fact must be acknowledged and addressed if the Christian faith is to be the “salt and light” that we are called to be to a world that is hurting in so many ways.

As a diocesan family, we are a diverse and complicated lot. We hold a range of views and have varying degrees of patience for the long engagement that has been with us and will continue to be with us for the foreseeable future. We hope that each member of this diocesan family is committed to walking together in mutual forbearance and love, which strengthens our witness both here and beyond our diocesan borders. This will require godly patience, Christ-like humility, and a holy willingness to “Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ” (Gal 6.2). In all that we do, let us remember “For what we preach is not ourselves, but Jesus Christ as Lord, with ourselves as your servants for Jesus’ sake” (2 Cor. 4.5).

More to come!

Gary Lillibridge, Bishop of West Texas
David Reed, Bishop Suffragan of West Texas

Presiding Bishop, HOD President Send Letter to Archbishop

Friday, July 17th, 2009

news-blue2DWTX from Anaheim – Episcopal Church Office of Public Affairs — A letter describing the steps taken by The Episcopal Church’s 76th General Convention and reaffirming the close relationship with the Anglican Communion was sent today to Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury, by Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori and House of Deputies President Bonnie Anderson. A copy of the letter also was sent to the 38 Primates and clergy and lay leaders of the Anglican Communion.

The letter to Archbishop Williams outlined Resolution D025, which was adopted at this General Convention, explaining that Presiding Bishop Jefferts Schori and President Anderson understood Resolution D025 to be more descriptive than prescriptive in nature. It stated that some are concerned that the adoption of Resolution D025 has effectively repealed Resolution B033 but reiterated that is not the case. The letter continued, “This General Convention has not repealed Resolution B033. It remains to be seen how Resolution B033 will be understood and interpreted in light of Resolution D025.”

The letter also states that the Episcopal Church “is deeply and genuinely committed to our relationships in the Anglican Communion.” It also says, “In adopting this Resolution, it is not our desire to give offense. We remain keenly aware of the concerns and sensibilities of our brothers and sisters in other Churches across the Communion. We believe also that the honesty reflected in this resolution is essential if indeed we are to live into the deep communion that we all profess and earnestly desire.”

The letter expresses the profound appreciation of the Presiding Officers that Archbishop Williams, 16 Anglican Primates, and lay and clergy leaders of the Anglican Communion attended the General Convention and stressed the importance of finding ways to communicate directly about different cultural and ecclesial contexts.

The letter to Archbishop Williams was hand-delivered. Copies of the letter were emailed to the Primates and to Anglican lay and clergy leaders on July 17, and were distributed to the House of Bishops and House of Deputies.

[See the gold tab "Resources" page for a complete copy of the letter.]

Convention Adopts Severely Reduced Triennial Budget

Friday, July 17th, 2009

news-blue2DWTX from Anaheim - Episcopal News Service – The 76th General Convention adopted a $141 million budget for 2010-2012 on July 16 that asks for less money from dioceses and drastically reduces church-wide spending by $23 million.

The House of Deputies spent approximately three hours debating the budget and rejecting all attempts to change its revenue or expense categories. The budget was then passed on a voice vote and sent to the House of Bishops, where it was approved.

The deputies had no stomach for adding money to the budget, despite repeated attempts to do so in six categories. David Abbott (East Carolina) at one point called it “less than totally responsible” to amend the budget.

“This committee has labored for over 60 hours … with complete transparency, agonizing to tears over the decisions they have made,” he said. “We must trust our committee. We cannot micromanage our budget, and I urge you, as I intend, to vote against each and every amendment to this budget.”

Some church-wide programs will be eliminated under the budget, encouraging more mission work to take place in dioceses and congregations. At least 30 of the 180 people employed by the Episcopal Church in its New York and regional offices could lose their jobs.

The next General Convention could be two days shorter, and interim church bodies will meet face-to-face less frequently during the triennium. The Episcopal Church’s provincial contribution to the budget of the Anglican Communion Office would decrease by a third.

PBF restored a budget line item dedicating 0.7 percent of income to U.N. Millennium Development Goals work that had been cut from a draft version of the budget, and added a corresponding percentage for domestic-poverty initiatives.

PBF’s proposal predicts total triennial income of $141,271,984, with $79,161,193 coming from the dioceses and $27.6 million from investment income. Expenses are budgeted at $140,856,531. Those figures compare with the projected bottom line of the current 2007-2009 triennial budget of $164,863,529 in revenue and $163,934,334 in expenses.

In January, the church’s Executive Council approved a draft 2010-2012 budget based on $161,820,613 in revenue and $161,791,177 in expenses.

After the deputies approved the budget, the Rev. Ann Fontaine (Wyoming) called for “a moment of silent prayer for all the staff that will be axed, that they might find healing and hope.” The Rev. Francis Wade (Washington), the house’s chaplain, led the deputies in prayer “for those who bear great responsibilities for that which we have chosen to do in this budget and for those who bear great burdens for what we have chosen not to do in this budget.”

The bishops’ chaplain, Brother Geoffrey Tristram, SSJE, noted the budget’s impact during his prayers that closed that house’s July 16 legislative work. He called on the bishops to pray for those Episcopal Church employees “whose positions have been eliminated or significantly reduced by passage of this budget; we hold them in our hearts.”

The deputies’ debate was unusual. Instead of debating the entire budget, the house agreed to debate separately the budget’s sections covering funding, program expenses (generally ministry and mission), corporate expenses (administrative support of the church center) and canonical expenses (offices of the Presiding Bishop and the president of the House of Deputies, in addition to General Convention and interim bodies). The entire budget was later approved on a single voice vote.

– Mary Frances Schjonberg is national correspondent for Episcopal News Service.

What Else Gen Con 09 Did

Friday, July 17th, 2009

news-blue2DWTX from Anaheim – Here is some of what else happened at the 76th General Convention, all from Episcopal News Service. You can read the full stories at http://www.episcopalchurch.org/107145_ENG_HTM.htm

Repentance for slavery has a long way to go, say advocates

Efforts to deal with the Episcopal Church’s legacy of complicity in slavery have been difficult and slow, and the church needs more time to deal with the issue, say several resolutions from the Social and Urban Affairs Committee.

In recent hearings at General Convention in Anaheim, members of the committee have considered resolutions A142, A143 and C050, which would extend and expand the Episcopal Church’s exploration of its role in the institution of slavery and its modern-day repercussions.

General Convention 2006 passed several resolutions on the subject of the church’s complicity in slavery as well as other forms of exploitation and abuse of non-white peoples. The resolutions called on dioceses to explore the history of slavery and its aftermath and to find ways to seek reconciliation and healing.

Deputies defeat resolution addressing the disclosure of litigation costs

The House of Bishops asked deputies to concur with their recommendation on C067 – proposed by the Diocese of West Texas — to refer the resolution to the Standing Commission on Stewardship and Development, but the House of Deputies did not concur. The resolution had called for revealing the dollar amount the church spent “on litigation against dioceses, parishes, groups of churches and individuals since General Convention 2006″ as well as information about where the funds came from, the money budgeted for litigation in the next triennium and “an estimate of the amount of property value retained and expected to be retained” by the church “because of pending and completed litigation as of General Convention 2009.”

“We all need to know about the litigation going on in our church,” said the Rev. Ellen Neufeld (Albany). “I speak very strongly in favor of this resolution so that information can be shared.”

Deputies debated various options, including referring it to the Joint Standing Committee on Program, Budget and Finance or substituting previous wording to direct the Presiding Bishop and Executive Council to release the litigation information.

Thomas Fitzhugh III (Texas) said he was concerned that the resolution could put the Presiding Bishop and Executive Council “in a bad spot” because divulging information about ongoing litigation would reveal strategy to the other side. “Let’s just kill it. This is nothing but an effort by people who try to steal our property” to find out how much the church has spent. “If they didn’t try to walk off with it, we wouldn’t have this motion.”

Deputies ultimately voted not to concur with the bishops’ recommendation, killing the legislation.

ERD Sunday encouraged, liturgy for companion animals proposed

The Prayer Book, Liturgy and Music committee recommended a long list of resolutions for consideration by General Convention.

Among others, the resolutions recommend establishing an Episcopal Relief and Development (ERD) Sunday during Lent; referring resolutions to the Standing Commission on Liturgy and Music (SCLM) that propose an alternate Baptismal Covenant and various calendar commemorations, including a possible creation season; directing SCLM to develop a rite to observe the loss of a companion animal; and directing the commission to confer with the Standing Commission for Constitution and Canons about matters affecting liturgical translations.

Resolution A178 originally asked for the first Sunday in Lent to be designated ERD Sunday, but several committee members objected either to designating a Sunday or to specifying that particular Sunday.

The amended resolution the committee recommended would “encourage dioceses, congregations and individuals to remember and support the lifesaving work of Episcopal Relief and Development during Lent through prayer and a special offering.”

The committee also recommended referring to SCLM an amended version of Resolution D005, which proposes an alternate Baptismal Covenant for possible inclusion in supplemental prayer book materials. The proposed rite rephrases the format of the affirmations so that those making the vows, rather than the celebrant, state the content of the affirmations. For example, the celebrant would ask, “How will you each remain faithful to these things you believe?” and the people would reply: “With God’s help, by continuing in the apostles’ teaching and fellowship, in the breaking of bread and in the prayers.” However, D005 was rejected by the House of Bishops.

Bishops delay decision on retired bishops’ voice and vote

The House of Bishops ended an emotional discussion July 17 by again delaying a long-sought decision about whether retired bishops should be able to vote.

Bishops voted 72-39 to refer Resolution A052 to the Standing Commission on Constitution and Canons to provide more time to study the issue. The issue will not resurface until another “first reading” at the 77th General Convention in 2012, where, if passed, it will require approval again at convention in 2015.

Several bishops expressed conflicting personal as well as theological feelings about excluding retired bishops from any official legislative role.

Questions on the authority of retired bishops have swirled within the church for decades. In 2000, the House of Bishops voted to eliminate retirees’ voting power, but the House of Deputies defeated that resolution. In 2003, the move passed in both houses, but it then was amended in 2006 to become yet another first reading.

The resolution would maintain seat and voice in the House of Bishops for all bishops but limit votes to bishops with jurisdiction; coadjutor, suffragan or assistant bishops; and “every bishop holding an office created by General Convention.” As a constitutional amendment, the resolution must pass two successive conventions with the same wording.

Bishops seek deeper relations with Presbyterians, Church of Sweden

The House of Bishops passed two resolutions July 8 that would bring Episcopalians into closer relationship with the Presbyterian Church (USA) and the Church of Sweden.

Both resolutions, A075 and A076 respectively, were sent to the House of Deputies for approval where they were later adopted.

The Presbyterian Church moved forward with the agreement during its General Assembly in 2008, but the action still must be ratified by a simple majority of the denomination’s 173 regional presbyteries. That ratification should be complete by the General Assembly’s next meeting in 2010. The denomination’s Committee on Ecumenical Relations is to oversee the continuing conversation on the agreement and report to the 220th General Assembly in 2012.

Bishops also passed a resolution calling for deepening relations with the Lutheran Church of Sweden. The resolution calls for the Standing Commission on Ecumenical and Interreligious Relations to “begin a dialogue” with the Swedish church in hopes of eventually forming a “relationship of full communion.”

Even with a sagging economy, Episcopalians still go shopping

General Convention’s Exhibit Hall encompassed about 300 10-foot by 10-foot booths filling nearly 30,000 square feet, representing more than 160 exhibitors, according to hall manager Artie Meyer. When the hall opened for business, they had “the biggest crowd we’ve ever had,” he said.

“We’ve been very fortunate this year in this down economy,” said Meyer. While some big trade shows have shrunk 30 to 40 percent, this year’s General Convention Exhibit Hall is about 3 percent smaller than in 2006, he said. “That’s pretty insignificant in the show business.”

“We’ve been growing 3 percent steadily every [convention] for about six conventions,” he added.

And it apparently was a hungry crowd. Based on projections three years ago, exhibit planners projected a 15 percent increase in show size and expanded the restaurant area 30 to 35 percent to accommodate a bigger crowd. “It actually looks like we’re going to get the increased crowd if today is any indication,” he said July 7. “I couldn’t be happier. My life is very peaceful when there’s a good crowd for a show.”

The actual results from the nine-day Exhibit Hall run were not available when the Convention ended on July 17.

Renewing dioceses embrace mission, evangelism

Bishops and deputies from four continuing Episcopal dioceses shared stories of energetic mission and renewal, transformation and evangelism during a July 7 live webcast from the 76th General Convention.

The representatives, from the dioceses of Pittsburgh, Quincy (Illinois), Fort Worth (Texas) and San Joaquin (California) also described warm welcomes at convention and gratefulness for the church’s support during their reorganizations.

Another deputy stopped the Rev. Dr. Jim Simons, a seven-time deputy and chair of the committee on dispatch of business, from Pittsburgh, in a convention hallway. “He said I know we disagree on a lot of things, but I’m so glad you’re here. I need you in my church.”

For others, like the Rev. David Madison, a first-time deputy from Fort Worth, there were “tangible acts of love, and support” such as gift bags and notes from the Diocese of Rochester, reminders that “we’re in their prayers and encouraging us for the work we’re doing. That’s very important to us”

The webcast is available on: http://www.episcopalchurch.org/gchub

International guests find new understanding of Episcopal Church polity

International guests attending General Convention, including almost half of the Anglican Communion primates, spoke of their amazement and gratitude as they gained a deeper understanding of the legislative processes of the triennial gathering and the polity of the Episcopal Church.

“I appreciate the history and openness of debating and coming together for worship,” said Archbishop Bernard Ntahoturi of Burundi, one of the more than 70 international guests who attended the General Convention, meeting July 8-17 in Anaheim, California.

Many of the guests said they were impressed with the size and structure of General Convention, whose legislative body is composed of about 845 deputies and more than 280 bishops.

Altar Guild officers installed at Los Angeles procathedral

New officers of the National Altar Guild Association were installed July 16 at St. John’s ProCathedral in Los Angeles by Bishop Suffragan of Texas Rayford High during a service of Holy Eucharist. The Rev. David B. Hoopes, OHC, former chaplain to the Altar Guild in the Diocese of Long Island, delivered the homily.

 Officers installed are: Jane Ames, president; Katrina Packard, first vice president; John York, second vice president; Connie Castillio, secretary; Dolores Miller, nominating chairman; Lynn Hendricks, treasurer.

Christian Formation Charter approved

(Report from Lou Taylor, diocesan Christian Forman Officer) The Charter for Lifelong Christian Formation, which has passed both houses of General Convention, will serve the Episcopal Church as a guide and framework for Christian formation for all people. The preamble to the charter states that “Lifelong Christian formation in the Episcopal Church is growth in knowledge, service and love of God as followers of Christ and is informed by scripture, tradition and reason.”

 The charter outlines many of the ways that God invites, inspires and transforms all people for a lifelong journey with Christ. It grew out of a perceived need to bring to the forefront the urgent necessity of being intentional about making Christian formation central to everything we do. It will serve as a template for the ministry of Christian formation.

What We Meant to Say Was . . .

Friday, July 17th, 2009

news-blue2DWTX from Anaheim – The Rt. Rev David Reed was not “elected to serve on a committee that would nominate persons for the position of Presiding Bishop if the current Presiding Bishop becomes incapacitated during her term of office” as was previously posted on this blog. However, both Susan Hardaway and the Rev. Ram Lopez were elected.

We regret the error.