DWTX from Anaheim — Deputies returned to their work as a “Committee of the Whole” Friday morning, July 10, as they heard from each other on what steps The Episcopal Church (TEC) should take next in regard to human sexuality.
On Thursday afternoon, deputies spent an hour talking one-on-one about their experiences. At the close of that session, deputies were each given a numbered token, and on Friday morning 50 of those token holders, chosen by lottery, were given two minutes each at a microphone.
In general, speakers lined up on either side of the question of what to do about resolution B033, passed at the 75th General Convention in 2006. That resolution asked TEC to “exercise restraint” in consenting to the election of openly gay bishops. The purpose of Friday morning’s discussion was to “inform” the World Mission Committee, to which several resolutions calling for the repeal of B033 have been assigned. Following today’s discussion, the World Mission Committee must still determine what it will do with several resolutions around the topic of human sexuality.
Basically, the arguments for or against repealing B033 fell into one of two lines of reasoning – is it a justice issue or is it a relationship issue? Those in favor of repealing B033 consider it a justice issue.
“I voted in favor of B033 three years ago,” said a deputy from North Carolina, “but only out of respect for [then] Presiding Bishop Griswold and [then Presiding Bishop elect] Bishop Jefferts Schori. “But I have changed my mind and my heart. B033 allows the church to discern who might have the gifts to teach the faith in this Church.” New Hampshire did not elect a gay bishop, he said, “It elected the best person for the job.”
Another deputy told of her life growing up in the church, when the doors were open to her until her mother declared her lesbian orientation. “Then the doors slammed shut,” said the deputy. They again slammed shut when the deputy discovered her own lesbian orientation. “B033 was another door slamming shut for me,” she said.
Deputy Louie Crew of the Diocese of Newark said that passing B033 “destroyed the credibility of every sign that says ‘The Episcopal Church Welcomes You’.” Several deputies admonished that the gay and lesbian community has sacrificed sufficiently, and that they should no longer carry the burden for the entire church.
But other deputies were not ready to repeal B033 or take any other action that would further split the Anglican Communion. “The irony of it is that this Convention seeks to celebrate ubuntu (togetherness) and yet is poised to rupture the communion even more,” said a Deputy from the Diocese of El Camino Real. He added that TEC has not made a theological case for the blessing of same-sex unions. “We take pride in our three-legged stool of tradition, reason, and scripture,” he said, “but we are going against scripture and using canonical procedures instead.”
Deputy David Luckenbach, formerly of St. Luke’s, San Antonio, and now in the Diocese of the Rio Grande, said in marriage counseling he was asked if he wanted to be right or wanted to be married. “In our part of the world,” he said, “B033 has been the catalyst for a cease fire. Not to throw anyone under the bus, but I would like to refrain from driving the bus over all of us.”
A deputy from Northern Indiana disputed the claim by some that B033 has accomplished nothing since it was passed. “It got our Presiding Bishop to the Primates Meeting, it got our bishops to the Lambeth Conference,” he said. “It has accomplished everything it was designed to accomplish.”
Committee work on all of the resolutions that address the topic of human sexuality continues in the days ahead with no indication of when resolutions might come to the floor of either house.